BetterHelp vs Talkiatry
BetterHelp vs Talkiatry compared. One is talk therapy at scale, the other is psychiatrist-led medication management. Both now take insurance. Here's which you actually need.
Quick answer
Between BetterHelp (3.9/5) and Talkiatry (4.2/5), there is no single winner: the best choice depends on your insurance, budget and what you are treating.
This is less a head-to-head than a fork in the road: BetterHelp is talk therapy (no medication), Talkiatry is psychiatry (medication management, with therapy as an add-on). Both are in network with major insurers, so what you need decides the winner.
Side by side
| BetterHelp | Talkiatry | |
|---|---|---|
| Service | Talk therapy | Psychiatry + meds (therapy add-on) |
| Verdict: Different services: BetterHelp for therapy, Talkiatry for psychiatry. | ||
| Insurance | Yes (125+ plans) or $70 to $100/wk cash | Yes (major insurers; no self-pay, no Medicaid) |
| Verdict: Both are in network with major commercial plans. BetterHelp also sells cash plans, and Talkiatry requires insurance it accepts. | ||
| Medication | No | Yes |
| Verdict: Talkiatry wins: BetterHelp cannot prescribe. | ||
| Best for | Counseling, largest therapist pool | Diagnosis + medication |
| Verdict: Depends on whether you need counseling or medication. | ||
Our verdict
Choose BetterHelp if you want talk therapy, especially if your plan covers it or you want to pay cash. Choose Talkiatry if you need a psychiatric evaluation and medication and have insurance it accepts. Many people use therapy and psychiatry together.
Frequently asked questions
Can BetterHelp prescribe medication?+
No. BetterHelp is talk therapy only. For medication you need psychiatry, such as Talkiatry.
Which takes insurance?+
Both. BetterHelp now accepts 125+ plans (average copay about $23 per session) and still sells cash plans. Talkiatry is in network with major insurers but has no self-pay option and does not take Medicaid.
More in Mental Health & Therapy.